Recipe: Simple, Greek-Style Yogurt

bs-fresh yogurt-banner

If you’ve got cows, you likely already know the joys of making your own yogurt. It’s easy, delicious, and oh-so-rewarding! If you don’t have cows, we think this recipe will convince you that you need some.

The following excerpt is from Keeping a Family Cow by Joann S. Grohman. It has been adapted for the web.


Making Yogurt

Milk from a high-milk-solids breed such as the Jersey makes the best yogurt. Use whole milk and you’ll get a little “frosting” of yogurty cream on top. I often make mine in eight-ounce ceramic pots, glass jelly jars, or coffee mugs. Sometimes I just fill a large pan with milk.

I have uneven success with yogurt unless I first scald the milk to destroy the competing bacteria, but this does forfeit some of the essential value of raw milk. The important point is that the milk must be between 90°F and 115°F to make yogurt. So you can scald your milk, then let it cool to this temperature, or if you don’t want to destroy the probiotics in raw milk, you can simply warm your milk to this temperature.

For yogurt starter, for every two quarts of milk, use about one-quarter cup (no more; the organisms don’t like to be crowded) of your last batch of yogurt or of a first-class brand of fresh plain yogurt, or use a commercial starter and follow the packet directions. When your milk is warm, add the starter, and stir it in gently but thoroughly with a very clean spoon. Pre-warm the vessels in which you plan to set your yogurt, then pour or ladle it in and cover them. Find a spot in your home that will keep the yogurt cozy, without allowing it to fall below 90 ̊F or heat it above 115°F. It is worth a bit of trouble to find the ideal spot for incubating your yogurt. Once you hit on the successful combination of container and heat source, you can make yogurt quickly and easily, without having to give it much thought. The incubation should take about four hours. Try not to jiggle the yogurt while it is setting or it will be runny.

If your yogurt is not as thick as you would like, there are several things you can do about it. To begin, note that raw milk yogurt tends to be less firm. To firm it up a bit, you can let it sit longer, or you can obtain fresh starter. Using a larger amount of starter is unlikely to be helpful. The yogurt organisms prefer not to be crowded. Do be sure to mix thoroughly. I usually make yogurt in one big pot and ladle out the whey as it accumulates. This has the effect of thickening the yogurt. You can make Greek-style yogurt by draining the whole batch of yogurt through a wet linen tea towel to remove some of the whey.

Read The Book

Keeping a Family Cow

The Complete Guide for Home-Scale, Holistic Dairy Producers, 3rd Edition

$19.95

Recent Articles

RECIPE: Summer Cherry Cornmeal Cobbler

It’s that time of year again: Outdoor barbecues are a weekend staple, trips to the beach and pool are becoming more frequent, and cherries are ripe for the picking! In their book, Cooking Close to Home: A Year of Seasonal Recipes, authors Diane Imrie and Richard Jarmusz provide a seasonal guide chock full of recipes…

Read More

No Forbidden Fruit: Life-Changing Applesauce Recipe

In her new book The Fruit Forager’s Companion, author Sara Bir encourages readers to embrace the magic of hunting for foraged fruit—delivering a how-to guide devoted to the secret, sweet bounty just outside our front doors. Bir, a seasoned chef, gardener, and forager, primes readers on foraging basics, demonstrates gathering and preservation techniques, and shares…

Read More

Recipe: Simple, Greek-Style Yogurt

If you’ve got cows, you likely already know the joys of making your own yogurt. It’s easy, delicious, and oh-so-rewarding! If you don’t have cows, we think this recipe will convince you that you need some. The following excerpt is from Keeping a Family Cow by Joann S. Grohman. It has been adapted for the…

Read More

Recipe: Country Elderberry Wine

There’s really nothing better than sitting down after a long day with a glass of wine and the sun setting in the distance. Unless of course you foraged for the berries for said wine, crushed them by hand, added in some sugar, water, and citric acid, bottled it up, and waited six months before you…

Read More

Daylily Dangers and Delights

Got some invasive daylilies taking over your garden? Instead of weeding them out why not eat them instead? A common vegetable in China and Japan, daylilies are more than a pretty flower. In her new book, Forage, Harvest, Feast, forager, and author Marie Viljoen describes their taste as “Green bean meets white asparagus by way…

Read More