Chelsea Green Publishing

Chelsea Green Blog

We Were Wrong: Pesticide “Roundup” Is as Safe as Coffee!</sarcasm>

My favorite thing about democracy is probably the free speech part. It’s amazing, really. Anyone can say anything! Like, our government’s audacity in trying to convince us we have fair healthcare in terms of what’s economically possible in this country, for one. And people who say homosexuals shouldn’t have legal rights like marriage, for another. Oh, and this guy, the Director of Medical Sciences and Outreach for Monsanto—the world’s leading producer of pesticides—who says that their big-selling weed killer, Roundup, is as safe as your morning cup of joe.

We received a response to our previous post on how Roundup, America’s favorite weed killer, may actually be damaging America’s pregnancies en masse. Not because we’re trying to sell an antidote, mind you (but I wish we could); just, you know, a piece of information we thought might inform the average consumer of something that’s otherwise neatly marketed as fine and dandy. According to this source, however—who is a mouthpiece for the company who produces Roundup—the weed-killer actually doesn’t kill human cells. The purportedly deadly pesticide is more like a café au lait, really, comparatively speaking. Special thanks to Monsanto for another of their speedy and brilliant efforts to combat criticism of their product on the blogosphere. For more examples, click here.

If you put a detergent of any sort on cells in a petri dish, the cells get sick. These Petri dish experiments, like the previous related experiments from Seralini’s group, have no relevance to a living animal and provide no information about real-world risks to humans. Instead, they tell us what we already know; that substances can injure unprotected cells in a test tube. To put this kind of study in context, consider that caffeine can also disrupt cell function. Caffeine was used in a similar Petri dish experiment also using cells from veins of human umbilical cords and produced the same result – cell death – by the same pathway (Matsuoka et al., 2006; see http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P3-1012804061.html).

Of course, caffeine – in its natural and added forms – is found in coffee, tea, cola beverages, new “energy” drinks, chocolate and even some medicines.

If you are interested in learning more about Monsanto’s position on Seralini’s studies, read this http://blog.monsantoblog.com/2009/06/23/seralini-safety-study/

Thanks so much,
Daniel A. Goldstein, M.D.
Director, Medical Sciences and Outreach
Monsanto Company


Tips on No-Till Farming and Cover Crops

In the below Q&A, author and permaculture designer Shawn Jadrnicek answers questions about no-till farming and the use of cover crops from two readers (one from North Carolina, and the other from Nova Scotia). In his groundbreaking book, The Bio-Integrated Farm, Jadrnicek provides in-depth information on water flow management along with projects that use the free forces of nature—gravity, […] Read More

Reimagining Restoration as a Radical Act

Finding ways to manage “invasive” species as we’ve come to know them has sparked a vigorous debate within conservation and restoration communities, as well as farmers, gardeners, and permaculturalists.In her thought-provoking book Beyond the War on Invasive Species, author Tao Orion urges us to rethink and reimagine restoration as a way to break out of […] Read More

What Can Wisteria Do For Your Forest Garden?

Jerome Osentowski, founder of the Central Rocky Mountain Permaculture Institute (CRMPI) in Basalt, Colorado, is one of North America’s most accomplished permaculture designers and author of the new groundbreaking book, The Forest Garden Greenhouse. Part case-study of CRMPI’s innovative greenhouses and part how-to primer, Osentowski’s book shows that bringing the forest garden indoors is possible, even on […] Read More

Tips on Perennial Crops with Eric Toensmeier

Eric Toensmeier is the award-winning author of Perennial Vegetables, Paradise Lot, and most recently The Carbon Farming Solution—a groundbreaking new book that treats agriculture as an important part of the climate change solution, rather than a global contributor to the problem. As part of our “Ask the Expert” series going on throughout the month of May to celebrate […] Read More

How to Design Swales for Optimum Water Flow

May has arrived! The birds are chirping, flowers are budding, and it’s time to officially celebrate Permaculture Month.Throughout the next few weeks, we are putting our pioneering permaculture authors to work for you in our “Ask the Experts” series. If you are looking to become a better permaculturalist, there’s still time to participate. Submit your questions here.Today’s topic is […] Read More
Follow us
Get every new post delivered to your inbox
Join millions of other followers
Powered By WPFruits.com