Chelsea Green Publishing

Chelsea Green Blog

Linda Faillace: USDA Won’t Allow Mad Cow Tests

When the USDA declared war on Linda Faillace (Mad Sheep: The True Story Behind the USDA’s War on a Family Farm) and her tiny sheep farm in an effort to stave off criticism of the government’s mishandling of Mad-Cow Disease, she fought back. Ultimately, her entire herd was destroyed while Linda and her family could only stand by, helpless. Though the disease has never appeared in any sheep, the USDA had found its fall guy.

Now, this inept arm of the US government—which is responsible for the safety of the food we consume—is calling for less testing of American cattle for Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (Mad-Cow disease) in the wake of test results that confirmed three cases of BSE in American cattle. Why is this happening?

How much longer should we defer to a governmental agency that has consistently failed to perform its duties? The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) is charged with protecting the American food supply, yet not a week goes by without another food-related health scare seizing headlines across the nation: listeria in pasteurized milk; spinach contaminated with E. coli; and potentially unsafe meat from “downer” cattle (animals which are sick or injured and unable to stand). This past spring tomatoes and peppers were accused of causing 1,442 illnesses and two deaths, yet the USDA is still unable to confirm the source of the salmonella infections.

These outbreaks are the results of decades of USDA policy decisions which favor corporations and industrial agriculture over small family farms and local production. Intensive animal and crop operations can lead to sick animals and tainted vegetables entering the food chain, and regulations which would prevent these incidents are often overlooked when corporate interests are at stake. A prime example is the USDA’s (mis) handling of Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE) or “mad cow” disease.

Europe has dealt with BSE for more than twenty-one years and has an extensive surveillance program in place: just last year approximately 9.7 million cattle were tested. While Europe tested millions, the USDA tested a few thousand and arrogantly proclaimed the United States was free of BSE, until the first case was discovered in 2003. Export markets dried up overnight. Japan and Korea, two of the largest importers of American beef, demanded the USDA either test for BSE or halt beef sales. The United States refused and a trade war quickly ensued. To date, tens of thousands of Koreans have taken to the streets to protest their government’s acceptance of untested American beef. Subsequently, Japanese and Korean top officials have been either severely criticized or forced to resign for allowing imports of US beef into their countries.

Creekstone Farms raises all natural, premium beef and had a very lucrative overseas market until the first case of BSE. Anxious to re-establish trade, Creekstone contacted the USDA to purchase BSE testing kits, but the USDA denied them access to the kits and threatened fines and even imprisonment if Creekstone attempted to test their cattle. Creekstone Farms filed a federal suit against the USDA, demanding the right to test. In 2007, a federal district court ruled in their favor. The USDA quickly appealed-and won.

In a decision last week, D.C. Court of Appeals Judge Karen LeCraft Henderson overturned the district court’s ruling and made repeated references to the fact that Congress gave the USDA broad powers. “We owe USDA a considerable degree of deference in its interpretation of the term, bearing, as it does, on USDA’s charge to ‘administer our federal meat and poultry inspection laws,'” she stated.

But the USDA does not deserve this deference. When the Humane Society released undercover footage of animal abuse and downer cattle going into the human food supply while USDA officials were on site, Americans were outraged and called for action. The USDA worked with the California-based company to organize the largest meat recall in history-143 million pounds. What the American public was not told was that the recall was for all the meat the company had produced over the previous two years, and the vast majority of it had already been consumed. The USDA should be supporting the decentralization of the beef industry. USDA inspectors were already on site, so more inspections would not have made a difference, nor would more regulations. The best suggestion is for the USDA to support smaller slaughterhouses instead of forcing them out of business with burdensome regulations necessary for the industrial meat processors.

Our family farm, which produced high quality breeding stock and gourmet cheese, experienced the USDA’s ineptness and corruption first hand when they targeted our healthy flock of sheep for BSE, a disease which does not exist in sheep. Our decade-long battle with the USDA and a subsequent lawsuit has revealed a laundry list of documented misdeeds against us including: destruction of evidence, suppression of test results, extensive undercover surveillance, and misleading and false statements given to the general public and our elected officials. The most egregious was an armed invasion of our family farm and the subsequent seizure and destruction of our animals and livelihood.

Read the whole article here.


How well do you know your charcuterie?

Prosciutto. Andouille. Country ham. The extraordinary rise in popularity of cured meats in recent years often overlooks the fact that the ancient practice of meat preservation through the use of salt, time, and smoke began as a survival technique. All over the world, various cultures developed ways to extend the viability of the hunt—and later […] Read More

Chelsea Green Weekly for May 5, 2017

Ever wonder what your favorite Chelsea Green authors do between writing groundbreaking–both literally and figuratively–books? Here are the best links and resources for your weekend reading pleasure. Let’s start with The Alzheimer’s Antidote. The Alzheimer’s Antidote Amy Berger has been making the rounds on the health, wellness, and fitness circuit, explaining the theories behind her revolutionary […] Read More

Learn from Chelsea Green authors this summer at Sterling College

Each summer, the School of the New American Farmstead at Sterling College in Vermont offers continuing education designed specifically for “agrarians, culinarians, entrepreneurs, and lifelong learners.” Chelsea Green is proud to partner with this program so you can learn from our expert authors in a hands-on, experiential setting at Sterling’s farm and teaching kitchen. Be sure to read […] Read More

4 Books for Growing Food in Winter

Don’t let cold weather stop you from producing and enjoying your own food. For many, the coming of winter simply means cultivation moves indoors or under cover. Small farmers, homesteaders, home gardeners, and commercial growers can extend the growing season with techniques outlined in these essential books. There’s no need for urbanites and small-space dwellers […] Read More

Is My Broth (or Stock) Bad?

Are you planning to start the GAPS diet or any other diet aimed at boosting gut health this year? If so, chances are that stocks and broths are critical components. Even if you’re not changing the way you eat, but you often have pots of aromatic goodness bubbling on your stove, you may have wondered, […] Read More
+1
Tweet
Share
Share
Pin