- Chelsea Green - www.chelseagreen.com -
Keeping kids’ toys safe
Posted By Shay On March 31, 2008 @ 3:49 pm In Chelsea Green Kids, Nature & Environment, Socially Responsible Business | No Comments
Journalist Mark Schapiro, whose book  Exposed was recently the basis for a special feature on PBS’  NOW program that focused on phthalates—a hard-to-pronounce but damaging group of chemicals found in many children’s toys—is taking on the chemical industry’s apologists.
Elizabeth Whalen took him to task earlier this year on The Huffington Post, calling him an “activist,” which to journalists is about as slanderous as it gets. Schapiro took up Whalen’s outing and used what all journalists use when they write stories—facts—to show that his book and his reporting are on firm ground, not simply based on alarmist claims.
And, in case you were wondering phthalates make plastics soft and pliable and chewy for kids—the reason why a rubber ducky is so darn inviting.
Here’s a sample of the back-and-forth:
Whalen: Contrast the activist scare about phthalates with the scientific reality: there is no evidence whatsoever—not even a hint—of health problems from phthalates in any consumer products used by children or adults. That is the conclusion of esteemed scientists from the Food and Drug Administration, Consumer Product Safety Commission, and universities around the world — and a blue ribbon panel on phthalates and health chaired by former Surgeon General C. Everett Koop. The issue has been addressed and studied extensively.
Schapiro: Dozens of studies of rodents and, increasingly, of humans have demonstrated precisely that: the evidence suggests strongly that phthalates disrupt the developing endocrine system of infant boys (at this stage, most of the research does focus on boys because phthalates affect production of the male sexual hormone, testosterone). A study published last week in the journal Pediatrics found evidence of phthalates in every one of the 163 infants under thirteen months that a team of scientists tested for the synthetic substance. Why does this matter? Studies in Denmark concluded in 2006 that high levels of phthalates in mother’s breast milk contributed to lower levels of testosterone production in their male offspring in the first three months of life.
After challenging Whalen’s claims, Schapiro has found a new foe in Trevor Butterworth, who offers a counter-argument Schapiro’s counter-argument  here. Here’s a snippet:
But there’s a problem: if you are going to muckrake with science, you need to be able to refute scientific evidence which doesn’t agree with your hypothesis. That’s how science works. Posit a theory, find evidence (or find data and posit a theory), test that evidence and theory against everything else out there.
This, Shapiro doesn’t do. He takes only the evidence that supports his position and avoids addressing the problems with it, even though these problems are substantial.
OK, Mark, the squishy phthalate-soaked ball is in your court.
Article printed from Chelsea Green: www.chelseagreen.com
URL to article: http://www.chelseagreen.com/content/keeping-kids-toys-safe/
URLs in this post:
 Exposed: http://chelseagreen.com/2007/items/exposed
 NOW: http://www.pbs.org/now/shows/412/index.html
 here: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/elizabeth-m-wheelan/hostages-in-the-war-again_b_85440.html
 riposte: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/mark-schapiro/the-case-against-phthalat_b_93092.html
 here: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/trevor-butterworth/the-case-against-worrying_b_93307.html