Chelsea Green Publishing

Chelsea Green Blog

Jamie Court: Will ‘Progressives’ Let Middle Class Burn to Prove Their Point?

When Anthem Blue Cross announced its controversial premium increases in California recently, the insurer claimed, “a carrier must be able to receive actuarially sound rates.”

So it is remarkable that “progressive” San Francisco State Senator Mark Leno, a single payer health care advocate, recently introduced eleventh hour legislation codifying Anthem Blue Cross’s “actuarially sound” defense of premium increases in law.

Advocates like me, who have battled the insurance companies for decades, know “actuarially sound” is code for whatever an insurance actuary says is “actuarially sound,” not what a regulator determines is really excessive.

Why would a single payer advocate, who wants to get rid of insurers, now want to give insurers more freedom?

It’s as though Leno is saying if he cannot beat the insurance companies with single payer, you might as well join them.

The conundrum is one progressives will have to grapple with: Why not let Rome burn and rebuild it, rather than making it better?

The answer for Senator Leno should be clear. He will have to face constituents who are forced to buy health insurance by 2014 or face tax penalties, and he will have made their health insurance more expensive.

Leno’s bill, SB 1163, undercuts a stronger proposal by State Senator Dave Jones, who will likely be the next California insurance commissioner and wants the power to say no to excessive premium increases. Leno’s bill is sucking support away from Jones’ AB 2578 because Leno is giving legislators an easier way — join with the insurers.

Progressives cannot afford to walk away from the suffering of the middle class to prove a point or make a case. Yet that’s the type of talk I am hearing more and more from progressives as the midterm approaches.

I am a single payer advocate but I also fight for premium regulation. I do it because I know it works and to help people who cannot afford their health insurance.

Twenty two years ago Consumer Watchdog’s founder Harvey Rosenfield reined in auto and home insurers’ premiums under the very same regulatory tools Senator Jones is trying to apply to health insurers. The Consumer Federation of America says Prop 103 saved motorists $62 billion on their auto insurance. You would think Leno might listen to people who saved insurance policyholders $62 billion if he really cared.

I fight for people like Mary Feller, whose individual Anthem Blue Cross policy was set to spike 39% when she held a press conference with me, Rosenfield and single payer advocates in the Bay area a few months ago. There was hardly a dry eye in the place when Mary talked about her health insurance premiums costing as much as her mortgage. The single payer advocates there also became supporters of premium regulation that day because they knew we had to do something. They knew you cannot let the middle class burn if you want to save it.

“I feel scammed by Anthem Blue Cross of California,” Feller said. “Using a corporate shell game and Draconian underwriting rules, they’ve trapped my family in a plan with costs that are spiraling out of control. It’s time to stop these unfair practices!”

The question for Senator Mark Leno is how does he look Mary Feller, who lives in his area, in the eye after his end-of-the-session shenanigans helping Anthem Blue Cross. It should be a cautionary tale for progressives. The view from the ivory tower is no way to take back the nation or the progressive movement. We need to see the struggles of the middle class from the streets.

Jamie Court is president of Consumer Watchdog and author of The Progressive’s Guide To Raising Hell: How To Win Grassroots Campaigns, Pass Ballot Box Laws And Get The Change We Voted For.

Follow Jamie Court on Twitter: @RaisingHellNow.

This article was originally published by The Huffington Post.

Use Systems Thinking to Make Lasting Social Change

What can be done when our best intentions create unintended problems—such as temporary shelters increasing homelessness or food aid accelerating starvation?After decades of helping change-makers in the nonprofit, public, and private sectors address tough social problems, systems-thinking expert David Stroh shares the pioneering framework that both demystifies systems thinking and shows how it can lead […] Read More..

Let’s Make Bernie Sanders a Bestseller!

As the presidential campaign of Bernie Sanders continues to climb in the polls, crushing online fundraising records and frustrating party insiders and pundits along the way, we’re looking to put Bernie’s message on bestseller lists everywhere in time for the national debates this fall!With the second Democratic debate to be held on November 14th in Des Moines, it’s […] Read More..

Bern Baby Bern!

Feel the Bern, now read the Bern. Chelsea Green is bringing out the first major book chronicling the issues being raised by US Senator Bernie Sanders in his campaign for president of the United States. The Essential Bernie Sanders and His Vision for America is the only book that outlines, in Sanders’ own words and […] Read More..

Economic Development is Broken. Here’s How to Fix It

Economic development today is completely broken. That’s the argument of author Michael Shuman in his new book, The Local Economy Solution. The singular focus on attracting global corporations is not just ineffective but counterproductive, Shuman argues, especially given the huge opportunity costs. Indeed, it’s not far-fetched to suggest that the best way most communities can […] Read More..

5 Shareable Strategies for Creating Climate Action

Frustrated about climate change? You’re not alone. Most people in our society find themselves somewhere on the spectrum of depressed about our climate situation to flat-out denying that it exists. In fact, the more information about global warming that piles up, the less we seem to do to combat it. What is the reason for this […] Read More..
Follow us
Get every new post delivered to your inbox
Join millions of other followers
Powered By