Chelsea Green Publishing

Chelsea Green Blog

Ask the Experts: Pasteurization and the Devil in the Milk

From time to time, we here at the offices (Well…”office,” singular. Well… two cubicles and a lamp…) of ChelseaGreen.com will get a question from a reader that we just can’t wrap our heads around. Sure, if the question relates to Battlestar Galactica (original and re-imagined), World of Warcraft, or how delicious cookies are, we’re all over it.

Example:
Q: How delicious are cookies?
A: Cookies are very delicious.

But beyond knowing the names of all the Thundercats, our knowledge base gets a little murky. That’s why we’re so glad we’re lucky enough to have a stable of expert authors, champing at the bit and rarin’ to go—with areas of expertise ranging from the US Constitution to composting to photovoltaics to urban gardening to wonky policy issues…and on and on.

This reader question about raw milk, milk pasteurization, and the A1 beta-casein protein came in from one of our Twitter friends. We ricocheted it over to Keith Woodford, author of Devil in the Milk: Illness, Health, and the Politics of A1 and A2 Milk, for his take on it.

I’m curious about whether pasteurization and homogenization has any impact on a person’s ability to process A1 beta-casein. I know that heat can change the structure of proteins, but don’t know enough about the science behind it to have any clue about whether or not raw milk might be healthier or safer in this particular respect.

Thanks very much,
Suzanne

 

Here’s Keith:

Suzanne,

There is no obvious reason why homogenization should affect the way that A1 beta-casein is broken down on digestion. Homogenization affects the fat molecules and how they are held together, but should not affect protein digestion. That is the theory, but sometimes theory can be proven wrong when more evidence comes in.   With pasteurization the story is more complex.  This is because pasteurization involves heat treatment and anything  over about 48 degrees Centigrade has the potential to cause denaturation of the proteins.  This may affect the way protein is digested. Corran McLachlan had a paper published in the Journal Medical Hypotheses in 2001 (Vol. 56, pp. 262-272) where he linked the increasing incidence of heart disease during the early and mid parts of the 20th century to early methods of pasteurization. I discuss this in my book (pp. 70-71). The early methods of pasteurization involved moderate heat for extended periods (the Holder method). McLachlan presented evidence across countries and regions that heart disease increased in the years following the introduction of pasteurization.  He also suggested that as pasteurization subsequently changed to methods using higher temperatures but for shorter periods, the denaturation may have been less. According to McLachlan, this may explain why heart disease rates declined somewhat in the second half of the 20th century despite no  decrease in the ‘classical ‘ risk factors.  McLachlan linked the impact to the increased release from A1 beta-casein of the peptide beta-casomorphin-7 (BCM7, or what I call the milk devil’).  Personally, I consider this pasteurization evidence very interesting but far from conclusive.  For example, pasteurization led to greatly increased milk consumption, particularly in urban areas, so that may explain some of the apparent effect. And the data itself has some reliability issues.  I would like to see properly conducted trials, with no dairy industry involvement, in further testing this hypothesis linking various pasteurization methods to release of A1 beta-casein.  Even if there is a relationship, it is important to remember that we already know enough to say with great confidence that some BCM7 will still be released from raw milk unless the milk is A2. Also, if pasteurization does have an affect, then so will any other form of  heat treatment used, for example, in making ice cream and custards, or in the manufacture of muesli bars that are held together by casein.

Thanks, Keith!

Be sure to check out Keith Woodford’s new book, The Devil in the Milk: Illness, Health, and the Politics of A1 and A2 Milk.


Recipe: How to Make the Perfect Pancake

When most people think pancakes, they think breakfast. But for Amy Halloran, breakfast is only the start. Halloran, author of The New Bread Basket, is a self-described pancake connoisseur. From a young age, she was entranced by the magic of bubbly batter rising to fluffy cakes on the griddle. Over time, her love of pancakes […] Read More..

What in the World is a Pawpaw?

Have you heard of the pawpaw? A few generations ago, most would say “yes!” You could ask just about anyone and they could tell you what this fruit looked and tasted like, and more importantly, where to find it. But today, the pawpaw remains a mystery to some and entirely unknown to others. In Pawpaw: […] Read More..

5 Creative Summer Drinks to Help You Cool Off

Now that we’re in the “dog days” of summer, the heat can feel a little unrelenting. There’s no better way to cool off than with a refreshing, cold beverage – especially when that beverage is made with local, organic ingredients and can give you an added health boost! While our experienced foragers and nutrition experts […] Read More..

Beat the Heat and Be Good to Your Gut: Dairy-Free Ice Cream Recipes

Recent research has shown that the trillions of microbes living in our gut, also known as our microbiome, can affect both our brain function and our mood and can be linked to a number of disorders ranging from allergies and asthma to autism, ADD, depression, and more. What we ingest can either help or hurt […] Read More..

Inside the Rise of the Local Grains Movement

Our daily bread. Breaking bread together. Bread and butter. These are all common phrases that reflect bread’s foundational role in our diet and in the building of our civilization. The stored energy of grain first allowed our ancestors to shift from nomadic hunting and gathering to building settled communities—even great cities. So why in an […] Read More..